Paula Deen, Uncle Bubba, and the Silence Over Sexual Harassment

Paula Deen with her brother Bubba Hiers, co-owners of Uncle Bubba's Oyster House.
Paula Deen with her brother Bubba Hiers, co-owners of Uncle Bubba’s Oyster House.

The Paula Deen fiasco that has unraveled over the past several days has me thinking about her brother Earl “Bubba” Hiers.  Specifically, where the hell is Uncle Bubba?  Because if you take a look at the original lawsuit, he is the one who needs his ass kicked all the way to Tybee Island for the hostile work environment created at the restaurant that carries his name.

To be clear, I still believe Paula Deen needs to be held accountable.  And for sure, she needs to offer a more sincere apology–one that doesn’t suggest that it’s about someone who wants what she has.  (See the the analysis of her Today Show interview.)  That may be true, but it doesn’t let Deen off the hook for her own racial missteps.

What boggles my mind, though, is the extent to which Paula Deen goes to cover for the men in her life, especially her brother.

In the lawsuit, we learn that her companies and her restaurant Lady & Sons is essentially a “Boys Club.”  And the boys, it turns out, behave badly.  Especially Uncle Bubba.

The lawsuit, moreover, isn’t just about a work environment damaged by racial slurs.  It’s very much about the ways that sexual harassment created a hostile work environment for women.

First, it is abundantly clear from the allegations that Uncle Bubba is the primary culprit for making racial slurs.  Yet what is also clear is that he regularly engaged in inappropriate workplace behavior and often used foul language when speaking to women or about women.

According to the lawsuit:

–Karl Schumacher, who is in charge of compensation for employees allegedly said that “women are stupid because they think they can work and have babies and get everything done.”

–Bubba Hiers allegedly either brought pornography to the restaurant or openly watched pornography “on the kitchen computer” where it was visible to several employees;

–Bubba Hiers allegedly made several sexual jokes in the workplace, criticized the “fat girls” who worked in the restaurant, told Lisa Jackson she had “nice legs” and to bring in photos of herself from when she was younger; and suggested that the restaurant staff be replaced with “Hooter’s girls.”;

–Lisa Jackson also alleges that Bubba Hiers “[grabbed] her face and [kissed] her and [spit] on her;”

And on, and on.

So, what’s much more clear now from Paula Deen’s deposition is that while she used a racial slur herself, she enabled the men who worked for her to continue their behavior by either ignoring the complaints brought to her attention, being willfully unaware of how her restaurants operated, and now, covering their asses–especially her brother Bubba.  This pisses me off, because while Deen is apologetic about the racial slurs, she hasn’t offered one apology for the sexual harassment.

But then, the media has ignored this aspect of the lawsuit as well as “Uncle Bubba’s” behavior.

Fortunately, we have reached a point in our society where many of us can rise up (and have) to say “no” to racism.  But we have NOT reached that point when it comes to sexual harassment.  In the public trial of Paula Deen, everyone’s been silent on this point. The media, Paula Deen, and her sons. Of course, Uncle Bubba has been silent about everything and is hiding behind his sister’s imaginary hoop skirt.

I, for one, think Earl “Bubba” Hiers needs to be held responsible for his behavior.  He should be dragged through the court of public opinion, too. The fact of the matter is that he’s gotten off easy.

If Deen’s use of a racial slur has proven there are consequences for doing so, then why not the same when it comes to sexual harassment?  There needs to be consequences for that, too.

That day can’t come soon enough.


8 thoughts on “Paula Deen, Uncle Bubba, and the Silence Over Sexual Harassment

  1. Using the N word is never acceptable, however it Is a part of American history. It has been written in books, used on television, used in jokes, etc. I live in the South, and have heard the word all my life, but it has been used all over this great country. I, like Paula ,have made the mistake and used the word, but I am not proud of it. She has apologized , and been dragged through the mud enough. If you have never made a mistake, you are truly a perfect person and I would like to meet you. Her livelihood is being taken from her, and her family has suffered a great embarrassment . She is a wealthy woman, and will be ok financially, but her character will be tarnished forever for making a mistake. Something we all do. And what about FREEDOM OF SPEACH!!!!

    • Just as one is free to speak, one must also be held accountable for that speech if it injures others. I am not crying any tears about her “livelihood.” She’s a multimillionaire and she will still be able to earn money. As for this post, the more important point was that her brother is really at the center of this case and he’s allowed Paula Deen to take the fall for his speech and actions. As I’ve been careful to cite from the lawsuit, these are allegations. Yet, when it comes to sexual harassment a person has to have pretty hard evidence or a lawyer would not have taken it. All it would take in this case is to review the metadata on the computer to reveal if porn sites were accessed. If that happens, then it makes the rest plausible.

  2. Enjoyed reading your blog and I agree with you that the alleged sexual, physical, and racial harassment in the workplace is far worse than the word Paula used. After chewing on this for awhile, I may have come up with a reason why the media has ignored it: Paula has admitted to using the word, but the workplace things are only allegations at this point. The lawsuit has not been settled at this juncture. If the media crucifies her with this information would they not open themselves to a lawsuit if the allegations turn out to be untrue? Just my thoughts…
    If you are interested in some bedtime reading, here is a link to Paula’s deposition, all 149 pages of it. Lengthy, but certainly eyeopening.

    • When the metadata from the computer is searched and reveals that porn sites have been accessed from the restaurant computer that’ll be all she wrote. I’ve read the deposition and the lawsuit in their entirety.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s